diff --git a/phpmon/Domain/DomainList/DomainListVC+Actions.swift b/phpmon/Domain/DomainList/DomainListVC+Actions.swift
index f271e417..f5da528e 100644
--- a/phpmon/Domain/DomainList/DomainListVC+Actions.swift
+++ b/phpmon/Domain/DomainList/DomainListVC+Actions.swift
@@ -12,6 +12,19 @@ import Cocoa
 extension DomainListVC {
 
     @objc func toggleSecure() {
+        if selected is ValetSite {
+            toggleSecureForSite()
+        } else {
+            toggleSecureForProxy()
+        }
+    }
+
+    func toggleSecureForProxy() {
+        // TODO: Handle this correctly
+        print("Will secure or unsecure proxy")
+    }
+
+    func toggleSecureForSite() {
         let rowToReload = tableView.selectedRow
         let originalSecureStatus = selectedSite!.secured
         let action = selectedSite!.secured ? "unsecure" : "secure"
diff --git a/phpmon/Domain/DomainList/DomainListVC+ContextMenu.swift b/phpmon/Domain/DomainList/DomainListVC+ContextMenu.swift
index 84f7888e..d0292f2c 100644
--- a/phpmon/Domain/DomainList/DomainListVC+ContextMenu.swift
+++ b/phpmon/Domain/DomainList/DomainListVC+ContextMenu.swift
@@ -43,7 +43,7 @@ extension DomainListVC {
         }
 
         addUnlink(to: menu, with: site)
-        addToggleSecure(to: menu, with: site)
+        addToggleSecure(to: menu, secured: site.secured)
 
         tableView.menu = menu
     }
@@ -130,9 +130,9 @@ extension DomainListVC {
         }
     }
 
-    private func addToggleSecure(to menu: NSMenu, with site: ValetSite) {
+    private func addToggleSecure(to menu: NSMenu, secured: Bool) {
         menu.addItem(
-            withTitle: site.secured
+            withTitle: secured
             ? "domain_list.unsecure".localized
             : "domain_list.secure".localized,
             action: #selector(toggleSecure),
@@ -146,6 +146,7 @@ extension DomainListVC {
         let menu = NSMenu()
         addOpenProxyInBrowser(to: menu)
         addSeparator(to: menu)
+        addToggleSecure(to: menu, secured: proxy.secured)
         addRemoveProxy(to: menu)
         tableView.menu = menu
     }