diff --git a/phpmon/Domain/SwiftUI/Domains/SecurePopoverView.swift b/phpmon/Domain/SwiftUI/Domains/SecurePopoverView.swift
index ea68b043..76667013 100644
--- a/phpmon/Domain/SwiftUI/Domains/SecurePopoverView.swift
+++ b/phpmon/Domain/SwiftUI/Domains/SecurePopoverView.swift
@@ -16,6 +16,7 @@ struct SecurePopoverView: View {
     @State var name: String
     @State var tld: String
     @State var expires: Date?
+    var callback: () -> Void = {}
 
     var body: some View {
         VStack(alignment: .leading, spacing: 10) {
@@ -41,6 +42,9 @@ struct SecurePopoverView: View {
                             message: "cert_popover.secure_domain_expired".localized(expires.formatted()),
                             color: Color.statusColorOrange
                         )
+                        Button("cert_popover.cta_renewal".localized) {
+                            callback()
+                        }.padding(.top, 10)
                     } else {
                         DisclaimerView(
                             iconName: "checkmark.circle.fill",
diff --git a/phpmon/Modules/Domain List/UI/Cells/DomainListTLSCell.swift b/phpmon/Modules/Domain List/UI/Cells/DomainListTLSCell.swift
index fd4a6811..22118617 100644
--- a/phpmon/Modules/Domain List/UI/Cells/DomainListTLSCell.swift	
+++ b/phpmon/Modules/Domain List/UI/Cells/DomainListTLSCell.swift	
@@ -58,7 +58,11 @@ class DomainListTLSCell: NSTableCellView, DomainListCellProtocol {
         let view = SecurePopoverView(
             name: site.getListableName(),
             tld: Valet.shared.config.tld,
-            expires: site.getListableCertificateExpiryDate()
+            expires: site.getListableCertificateExpiryDate(),
+            callback: {
+                App.shared.domainListWindowController?
+                    .contentVC.checkForCertificateRenewal()
+            }
         )
 
         let controller = NSHostingController(rootView: view)
diff --git a/phpmon/Modules/Domain List/UI/DomainListVC.swift b/phpmon/Modules/Domain List/UI/DomainListVC.swift
index 8edeb971..6d78dd68 100644
--- a/phpmon/Modules/Domain List/UI/DomainListVC.swift	
+++ b/phpmon/Modules/Domain List/UI/DomainListVC.swift	
@@ -40,6 +40,11 @@ class DomainListVC: NSViewController, NSTableViewDelegate, NSTableViewDataSource
     /// String that was last searched for. Empty by default.
     var lastSearchedFor = ""
 
+    /// Set to true if we already checked for expired certificates.
+    /// This prevents notifications about expired certificates from
+    /// popping up when we re-open the Domains window.
+    var didCheckForCertRenewal: Bool = false
+
     // MARK: - Helper Variables
 
     var selectedSite: ValetSite? {
@@ -63,6 +68,8 @@ class DomainListVC: NSViewController, NSTableViewDelegate, NSTableViewDataSource
         return domains[tableView.selectedRow]
     }
 
+    /// Timer used to determine whether this window has been busy
+    /// for a certain amount of time.
     var timer: Timer?
 
     // MARK: - Display
@@ -127,7 +134,11 @@ class DomainListVC: NSViewController, NSTableViewDelegate, NSTableViewDataSource
 
     override func viewDidAppear() {
         super.viewDidAppear()
-        checkForCertificateRenewal()
+
+        if !didCheckForCertRenewal {
+            checkForCertificateRenewal()
+            didCheckForCertRenewal = true
+        }
     }
 
     private func reloadDomainListables() {
diff --git a/phpmon/en.lproj/Localizable.strings b/phpmon/en.lproj/Localizable.strings
index df394b4f..ed826631 100644
--- a/phpmon/en.lproj/Localizable.strings
+++ b/phpmon/en.lproj/Localizable.strings
@@ -919,6 +919,7 @@ If you want to make edits to this file, please do so before upgrading. When you
 "cert_popover.secure_domain_traffic" = "Because this domain has been secured with a certificate, traffic to this domain is served by nginx over HTTPS.";
 "cert_popover.secure_domain_expired" = "The certificate expired on %@. You must renew it to continue using HTTPS without errors.";
 "cert_popover.secure_domain_expiring_later" = "The certificate is valid. It will expire on %@. At that point it will need to be renewed, but you will be notified.";
+"cert_popover.cta_renewal" = "Renew Certificates...";
 
 "cert_alert.title" = "One or more certificates have expired, and must be renewed.";
 "cert_alert.description" = "Certificates used to secure domains are usually valid for one year. Do you want PHP Monitor to unsecure and re-secure any expired domains?";
@@ -926,6 +927,6 @@ If you want to make edits to this file, please do so before upgrading. When you
 
 %@
 
-PHP Monitor will tell Valet to unsecure and re-secure all expired domains for you. This can take a while, as nginx may be restarted a few times if multiple domains need to be re-secured. You will be prompted about this issue every time this window opens, so it is recommended to take action now.";
+PHP Monitor will tell Valet to unsecure and re-secure all expired domains for you. This can take a while, as nginx may be restarted a few times if multiple domains need to be re-secured.";
 "cert_alert.renew" = "Re-secure Domain(s)";
 "cert_alert.cancel" = "Not Now";